September 11, 2007
sponsored by Tavant
ISSN 1550-9214         

Automotive Warranties:

Are claims soaring or falling? It depends how you slice the market. One way is to compare OEMs to their suppliers. Another is to group OEMs by the size of the vehicles they make. Either way, passenger car and light truck makers always seem to end up paying the most.

Depending on where you look in the automotive warranty chain, first half expenses were up either a lot or a little.

If you look at just small vehicle manufacturers, warranty claims soared 18% in the first half of 2007, compared to a year ago. But if you look at just parts manufacturers, claims were up only a slight 0.6%. Truck and heavy equipment manufacturers, meanwhile, saw claims rise almost 9% during the first half.

It all depends on how one does the counting. For this exercise, we started with a list of 231 US-based and publicly-traded companies that are either completely or partially in the automotive business, taking a look at their first-half 2007 warranty expenses. Of those 231 companies, 146 would probably call automotive their primary business, while 85 others derive the bulk of their revenue from industries such as HVAC, aerospace, telecom or semiconductors.

That doesn't mean they're not automotive suppliers or vehicle manufacturers. But it does mean that half or more of their warranty expenses probably don't belong under the automotive heading. So what we've done is set those 85 companies off into their own special category: "Other Suppliers." Companies such as Motorola, Honeywell, American Standard, Black & Decker, and Textron, for which automotive is an important market but not their primary industry, are grouped into this category.

Nothing But Auto Parts

Then there are approximately 104 companies that do little else besides manufacture components, parts, and systems for vehicles, which we shall call "Parts Suppliers." We can safely estimate that most if not all of their warranty expenses belong in the automotive category.

And then there are the vehicle manufacturers or the OEMs. In the chart below, the OEMs are depicted in blue, while the parts suppliers are depicted in light blue. The "Other" companies are depicted in red.


Figure 1
Automotive Manufacturers:
Quarterly Warranty Claims Paid, 2003 to 2007
(in $ millions)

Figure 1


The total first half warranty expense for OEMs was $5.4 billion, up 1.1%. For the middle band of parts suppliers, warranty expenses were up 0.6% to $846 million. And for the partially automotive companies, warranty expenses were up 4.1% to just over $1 billion. The quarterly totals for these categories going back to 2003 are detailed in Figure 1.

The sums paid by OEMs are huge, but keep in mind that the bulk of that is traceable to the vehicles of just two OEMs: Ford Motor Co. and General Motors Corp. But because their sales revenue is also huge, their warranty expenses end up averaging about 2.5% of their auto product revenue (total revenue minus finance, service, rental, credit card, and other non-warranted sources of revenue).

Suppliers Always Lower

For their suppliers, the percentages are even lower. How much lower? Figure 2 contains three lines, showing the calculated percentages of revenue that the amounts in Figure 1 represent. The all-OEM average is slightly below the 2.5% mark set by GM and Ford, suggesting that the makers of other types of vehicles pay out less than the passenger car and light truck makers. The "Other" suppliers have been around 1.0% to 1.2%, but have risen to the 1.5% to 1.7% range this year. And the plain old parts suppliers are still very close to their 0.6% to 0.7% historical average.


Figure 2
Automotive Manufacturers:
Quarterly Warranty Claims Paid, 2003 to 2007
(as a % of sales)

Figure 2


Interestingly, the figures for parts suppliers as a group, which had been showing signs of an upward tilt last year, have fallen back again this year. Some individual parts manufacturers have seen a big upturn in their warranty expenses as OEMs continue trying to push back more and more of their claims to their suppliers. But as a group, the numbers have barely moved. And while the trend is up for suppliers who are only partially automotive, who's to say whether the automotive sector is the source or the reason for these increases?

As mentioned, Ford and GM account for the bulk of the OEM segment. How much they represent is made clear in the pie chart of Figure 3. Readers should note that for this calculation we have added in some of the companies that are only partially vehicle makers -- such as Textron and Ingersoll-Rand -- in an effort to fatten up the other wedges. And we added in some of the companies making boat engines and other parts not meant for land-based vehicles. But Ford and GM still end up accounting for 75% of the pie.


Figure 3
Automotive OEMs by Vehicle Size:
Warranty Claims Paid, 2007
(as a % of OEM total)

Figure 3


The list of companies not included in Figures 1 to 3 stretches from internationally-based parts suppliers such as Robert Bosch, Autoliv, and Magna, to internationally-based OEMs such as Toyota, Honda, and DaimlerChrysler. The latter will soon revert back to US-based status, but it will then be privately-held. So that change of status will actually decrease the company's warranty disclosures.

As a courtesy to American regulators and investors, DaimlerChrysler AG has been making quarterly warranty disclosures since 2003. Also as a courtesy, Toyota and Honda have added warranty disclosures to their annual reports since 2003. So in each case, we've taken their warranty expense and divided it by automotive revenue, calculating the percentage of sales that warranty represents. Those percentages are detailed in Figure 4.


Figure 4
Top US Passenger Car Manufacturers:
Quarterly Warranty Claims, 2003 to 2007
(as a % of product sales)

Figure 4


Notice that there's no data for either Toyota, Honda, or DaimlerChrysler for the second quarter of 2007. There's also no data for DaimlerChrysler's first quarter. And there probably won't be. Such is life when depending upon voluntary disclosures, and when attempting to compare them with the required disclosures of GM and Ford. What we've done is added horizontal dotted lines for each company, which will have to suffice until and unless they make further disclosures.

Figure 4 does, however, show that while GM and Ford have behaved as twins around the 2.5% to 3.0% level, Toyota and Honda have behaved like twins at the 1.0 to 1.2% level. What this means is that the Japanese companies are spending half as much per unit of revenue on warranty as their American counterparts. It doesn't much matter what currency is used, because the currency cancels itself out during the calculation.

DaimlerChrysler Sets Records

And while GM and Ford on the one hand and Toyota and Honda on the other hand have generally kept their warranty expenses steady in a comfortable range, DaimlerChrysler has seen its claims rate swing from 2.7% to 5.2% then back down to 3.6%. And with the recent strength of the euro, DaimlerChrysler has held onto the unwanted title of world's largest warranty provider for multiple years. No wonder it discontinued filing courtesy reports of its warranty expenditures. Had charts like this appeared in the automotive press a year or two ago, even Cerberus might have been scared away.

But there's so much more to the automotive market than just this handful of passenger car and light truck OEMs. We could organize the rest of the OEMs by type of vehicle: farm, lawn, construction, sports, or utility. But for this exercise, we're going to group them by size. Anything bigger than a pickup goes into the truck and heavy equipment category. Anything smaller goes into the small vehicle category.

Figure 3 above detailed the warranty expense for each of these categories. Figure 5 below calculates the percentages these amounts represent of total product revenue. As the chart shows, Ford and GM are also atop this segmentation, with large vehicle manufacturers around 2% and small vehicle manufacturers around 1.5%.


Figure 5
Automotive OEMs by Vehicle Size:
Warranty Claims Paid, 2007
(as a % of product sales)

Figure 5


To create these segments, we started with a list of 48 US-based OEMs. Not counting the six companies manufacturing either boats or railroad vehicles, and not counting either GM or Ford, left 40 companies to allocate to either the small or the large vehicle categories.

Twelve manufacturers of motorcycles, golf carts, all-terrain vehicles, forklifts, and riding lawn mowers were placed in the small category. Everything else -- from ambulances to dump trucks -- was placed into the large category.

Readers who would like detailed charts for each of these segments can contact the editor. Much of the data in Figures 1 to 5 is repeated in these charts, however. So it probably doesn't deserve repeating here. But several readers have asked particularly for some data on heavy industry, so perhaps this offer will suffice.

Spotlight on Four OEMs

What we wanted to do with our remaining column space is spotlight two large and two small vehicle manufacturers, to provide some perspective on why the averages end up where they do. First we'll take a look at Caterpillar and Navistar, and then we'll look at Textron and Harley-Davidson.

None of these companies has quite the heft to move the averages like GM and Ford do, but Caterpillar is after all the third largest automotive warranty supplier. It reported $745 million in warranty claims last year, and so far in 2007 has reported $426 million for the first half. Its latest claims rate of 2.1% is up somewhat from a year ago, as is its accrual rate.


Figure 6
Caterpillar Inc.
Quarterly Warranty Claims & Accruals, 2003 to 2007
(in $ millions and % of sales)

Figure 6


In Figures 6 through 9, the blue columns represent the amounts spent each quarter on warranty claims. The green lines represent the percentage of sales set aside each quarter as warranty accruals, and the red lines represent warranty claims as a percentage of sales. In Caterpillar's case, the rise in claims and the steady-to-declining percentages suggest that sales are rising faster than warranty spending, which is in fact the case. This means that quality is increasing, or at least that defects are costing less to fix.

Now some would argue that Cat isn't automotive at all, but instead belongs in the heavy industry category. As proof, one need look no further than its operation that manufactures turbines used in power stations. However, its diesel engines go into on-highway trucks, so not everything it makes is meant for off-road work. So instead of looking for a vocation, we simply ask: is it bigger than an F-150 pickup truck? And in Caterpillar's case, the answer is definitely yes. So it definitely belongs in the "large vehicle" category.

This is the same problem we have with trying to sort these OEMs into narrow vehicle types such as heavy trucks, buses, recreational vehicles, emergency vehicles, construction equipment, and so on. Very few companies make just one thing or the other. They might make both trucks and buses, both fire trucks and street sweepers, or maybe both lawn mowers and farm machinery. Some of their products might have engines but no wheels. Others might have wheels but no engines.

Crossing Multiple Categories

Navistar is one of those companies that crosses several categories in terms of both vehicle type and vocation. And like Cat, it's both an OEM and a supplier, making engines for Ford's light trucks. But as of now, it hasn't filed a financial statement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in two years. So the last report of the company's warranty expenditures was for the fiscal quarter ended July 31, 2005.

In Figure 7, the seven missing quarters are shaded gray, and are set to equal the last known report of $65 million per quarter. The claims rate is a dotted line at the last known rate of 2.4%. And the accrual rate is set to the last known rate of 2.1%. At some point, the company is going to have to catch up with its filings, and we'll know whether warranty expenditures have increased or decreased in the past two years. Until then, however, there's a hole in the data -- even with these placeholder estimates.


Figure 7
Navistar International Corp.
Quarterly Warranty Claims & Accruals, 2003 to 2007
(in $ millions and % of sales)

Figure 7


An example of the opposite effect can be seen in Figure 8, where Textron's quarterly warranty expenses were estimated for three years, but now they're not. What happened is this: during 2003, 2004, and 2005, the company reported its warranty expenses only once a year, in its annual report. But then in 2006 and 2007, it changed to a quarterly disclosure format, as is required by the FIN 45 accounting rule. So what we're getting now is more frequent reports, which results in more variability.

Textron is one of the companies we placed into the "Other" category, because most of its manufacturing revenues come from Bell helicopters and Cessna airplanes. Only about 28% of its total revenue comes from industrial or automotive product lines such as forklifts, golf carts, and lawn care machinery. But the presence of those product lines also gives it a deserved slot in the "Small Vehicle" category.


Figure 8
Textron Inc.
Quarterly Warranty Claims & Accruals, 2003 to 2007
(in $ millions and % of sales)

Figure 8


It's not as if Textron's warranty expenses have been increasing, or that they're now more volatile than before. The claims rate has been very close to 1.5% for three years. And in fact, 1.5% is more or less the long term average claims rate in the whole small vehicle category.

But keep in mind that Textron typically accounts for a third of all the warranty spending in the small vehicle category. So perhaps it's no surprise that both averages are both around 1.5%, just like it's no surprise that the overall automotive OEM averages are close to the numbers put up by heavyweights such as GM and Ford.

In Figure 9, we're detailing the warranty expenditures of another heavyweight of the small vehicle category: motorcycle manufacturer Harley-Davidson. The company typically accounts for an additional 15% of the small vehicle category. But as can be seen in the chart below, its warranty claims rate has never even approached 1.5%, though it has been rising this year.


Figure 9
Harley-Davidson Inc.
Quarterly Warranty Claims & Accruals, 2003 to 2007
(in $ millions and % of sales)

Figure 9


It's not so easy to conclude that some small vehicles create more warranty expense than others. For while Textron's expenses are up around 1.5% of total revenue, who's to say it's not coming mostly from airplanes and helicopters? Then again, other forklift manufacturers such as NACCO Industries are also around 1.5%, and other lawn equipment manufacturers such as Briggs & Stratton and Toro are around 1.6% to 1.7%. So perhaps 1.5% is the "natural" rate for small vehicles, and motorcycles are naturally lower?

The point is, there are not so many companies like Harley-Davidson that make only one type of vehicle. What's more common is a product mix like Textron's -- not only of vehicle types but also of industries. And while many companies clearly identify their finance and service revenue (and Harley its apparel licensing/royalty revenue), some don't, which artificially depresses their claims and accrual rates.

But what's extremely clear is that the type of automotive company that usually ends up with the highest rate of warranty expense is a company that makes passenger cars and light trucks for a primarily consumer customer base. Ford and GM don't have the highest claims rates in the industry, but their rates are higher than the averages turned in by makers of vehicles both larger and smaller.

Tavant

 

This Week’s Warranty Week Headlines

Service Contract Industry Council touts extended warranties im era of shrinking manufacturers' warranties.
Press Release, September 11, 2007
HP ProCurve switch gets a transferrable lifetime warranty.
PC World, September 11, 2007
Asus Computer adds free year of accidental damage protection to laptop warranties in US/Canada.
Press Release, September 10, 2007
Fulcrum Warranty Solutions announces eXclaim Intelligent Claims Analyzer tools.
Press Release, September 10, 2007
Delphi seeks approval from bankruptcy court of a warranty claims settlement with GM.
Reuters, September 10, 2007
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Mize Warranty Connect

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Better Business Bureau calls home warranties a "problem industry" due to denied claims.
Charlotte Observer, September 9, 2007
BestTalkRadio.com's new warranty and service industry talk show reports 3,000 Internet downloads.
Press Release, September 9, 2007
Judge orders Ford and Navistar to mediate engine fight.
Bloomberg News, September 8, 2007
Over 20 auto manufacturers part of BBB Warranty Dispute Settlement Program.
Press Release, September 8, 2007
Domestic & General accepts £524m bid from private equity firm Advent International.
Times of London, September 7, 2007
 

More Warranty Headlines below



PCMI - Your technology partner

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Nortel Networks wins $10 million judgment in warranty fraud case against two companies.
Reuters, September 7, 2007
C&D Technologies increases warranty reserves because of higher raw material costs.
Press Release, September 7, 2007
Son of judge in Honda odometer case withdraws as counsel in similar lawsuit against Nissan.
Southeast Texas Record, September 6, 2007
Gateway to sell Professional Business Segment, including warranty support role, to MPC Corp.
Press Release, September 5, 2007
TV station compiles dozens of complaints against American Home Shield over denied claims.
WREG-TV Memphis, September 5, 2007
 

More Warranty Headlines below



After Warranty Analytics

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Electrical motors for power steering could cut warranty costs and raise fuel efficiency.
Associated Press, September 5, 2007
Dell opens new regional distribution hub in the UAE for warranty services in the Middle East.
Bahrain Tribune, September 5, 2007
SigmaQuest CEO Nader Fathi to conduct workshop Sep. 24 at Warranty Management Summit in Chicago.
Press Release, September 4, 2007
Unscheduled shutdown of Australian nuclear power plant seen as a warranty issue.
Australian Broadcasting Corp., September 3, 2007
Illinois gets part of $16.7 million payout by Boston Scientific Corp. over Guidant pacemakers.
Peoria Journal Star, September 3, 2007
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Sign up for a free subscription to Warranty Week:
     subscribe     change of address     unsubscribe


 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

UK buyers of new Kias to get one year of Kiassist free roadside recovery, down from three years.
What Car? September 3, 2007
Error 41 is the codename for an alleged defect in Brother inkjet printer heads.
New Zealand Press, September 3, 2007
Jacky's Electronics to offer extended warranties in the United Arab Emirates.
Press Release, September 1, 2007
N.E.W. Customer Service Cos. Inc. to hire 300 work-at-home call center agents in Wichita Falls TX.
Dallas Business Journal, August 31, 2007
Better Business Bureau gets complaint about company not honoring 500% money back guarantee.
Inside Tucson Business, August 31, 2007
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Entigo

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Wyoming gets part of $16.7 million payout by Boston Scientific Corp. over Guidant pacemakers.
Associated Press, August 31, 2007
Boston Scientific, Guidant, and Cardiac Pacemakers settle 35-state lawsuit for $16.7 million.
Press Release, August 30, 2007
Zenn Motor Co. picks 4CS iWarranty and iParts software solutions for warranty claims processing.
Press Release, August 30, 2007
Zale Corp. says jewelry extended warranty sales topped $111 million in fiscal 2007.
Press Release, August 30, 2007
Mazda UK adds 12-month warranties to its ZZ+ Approved Used Car Programme.
Press Release, August 30, 2007
Chrysler searches for dealer with the most creative and informative Lifetime Powertrain Warranty-themed TV commercial.
Press Release, August 30, 2007
Fujitsu Telecommunications Ireland launches out-of-warranty laptop support in UK.
Press Release, August 30, 2007
Lemon laws don’t always protect car buyers from vehicles moved across state lines.
New York Times, August 29, 2007
Maxol service stations across Ireland to pump 5% ethanol; auto warranties unaffected.
Irish Examiner, August 29, 2007
Homeserve walks away from Domestic & General takeover talks.
Times of London, August 29, 2007
Smith & Wesson to repair new California Highway Patrol handguns under warranty.
Associated Press, August 29, 2007
AT&T and Apple may face an uphill battle prosecuting hackers who unlock iPhones.
Business Week, August 28, 2007
Rumor has it that Microsoft Xbox 360 repairs now take six weeks because of increased volume.
Kotaku, August 28, 2007
Workers' advice raises Ford quality, lowers warranty claims at pilot plant.
Detroit Free Press, August 28, 2007
Australian army general downplays TV reports of defects in weapons used in Iraq.
Australian Associated Press, August 28, 2007
Home warranty company delays replacement of air conditioner's compressor for a month.
KJRH-TV Tulsa, August 28, 2007
Anaren Inc. identifies accounting errors with warranty expense and allowance for sale returns.
Press Release, August 28, 2007
Costco CEO discusses two-year warranties replacing unlimited return policy.
Wall Street Journal, August 27, 2007
Acer to acquire Gateway for $710 million, derails Lenovo plan to acquire Packard Bell.
Computerworld, August 27, 2007
BenQ-Siemens mobile handset owners in Russia lose warranty coverage as of August 2007.
CNews, August 27, 2007
Asus Technology opens warranty center in Ho Chi Minh City.
Vietnam Net, August 27, 2007
Retailers find HDTV profits fading away, so top-line electronics and warranties being pushed.
New York Times, August 26, 2007
City council votes to sell "lemon" fire engine back to its manufacturer.
Russellville News-Democrat & Leader, August 24, 2007
Snap-on Business Solutions says GM Electronic Parts Catalog in final phase certification process.
Press Release, August 24, 2007
Apple sells refurbished iPhones backed by one-year warranty.
Computing, August 24, 2007
Apple is just the latest company warming to the idea of selling refurbished mobile phones.
Business Week, August 23, 2007
GE Money’s Warranty Services Division to work with AppOne’s Internet-based auto finance platform.
Press Release, August 23, 2007
NPD says game console sales up 140% in July; Xbox 360 down 18%, smaller drop than expected.
Reuters, August 23, 2007
Consumer goes through three refurbished handsets then cancels mobile phone contract.
KYW-TV Philadelphia, August 23, 2007
Attorney Glenn Killoren joins Barnes & Thornburg LLP’s Elkhart office as a partner.
Press Release, August 23, 2007
Tampa residents get suspicious over auto extended warranty telemarketing calls from Nevada.
WTSP-TV Tampa, August 23, 2007
Fedders Corp. files petition for Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization.
Press Release, August 22, 2007
Samsung Electronics America uses ServiceBench to optimize its North American service network.
Press Release, August 22, 2007
New AIAG guidelines aim to improve quality of automotive parts and reduce warranty claims.
Press Release, August 22, 2007 (PDF file)
SigmaQuest posts two return-on-investment calculators online to highlight possible payback.
Press Release, August 22, 2007
Kenworth ranks highest in J.D. Power heavy-duty truck customer satisfaction survey.
Press Release, August 22, 2007
Land Rover dealer Alfardan Premier Motors in Qatar lengthens warranties to five years/150,000 km.
Press Release, August 22, 2007
Discounted bicycle helmets come with 12-month crash replacement warranty.
Oxford Mail, August 22, 2007
To highlight manufacturing quality, Renault equips new Laguna with three-year warranty.
Press Release, August 21, 2007
Anti-theft "immobilizer" units mandated in Manitoba may affect vehicle warranties.
Winnipeg Sun, August 21, 2007
Nokia will replace 300,000 Matsushita-made mobile phone batteries in India.
Bloomberg News, August 21, 2007
Great Wall Motor Co. vehicles in Botswana carry one-year warranty; two-year warranties for sale.
All Africa, August 21, 2007
Chrysler's warranty costs may be down, but they still top competitors’ warranty costs.
Automotive News, August 20, 2007
Consumer seeking refund on an unused vehicle service contract gets the runaround.
KOVR-TV Sacramento, August 20, 2007
Vacuum salesman won't honor money-back guarantee until headquarters intervenes.
WATE-TV Knoxville, August 20, 2007
Night editor's Xbox 360 freezes up; repair to take two to three weeks.
Kotaku, August 20, 2007
La-Z-Boy initially stands behind denied claims policy of Stainsafe until readers chime in.
Orlando Sentinel, August 19, 2007
Dell to restate earnings back to 2003 after completing accounting investigation.
Press Release, August 16, 2007
Sony Computer Entertainment Europe founder says PS3 failure rate is under 0.02%.
GamePro, August 16, 2007
Jack Barcroft and Will McCusker to host Internet radio talk show about warranty and service.
Press Release, August 16, 2007
Snap-on Business Solutions to implement a warranty solution for IC Frith & Associates.
Press Release, August 16, 2007
Reporters investigate consumer complaints about warranty claims denied by Stainsafe.
KLAS-TV Las Vegas, August 15, 2007
Advertising expert says Chrysler could trim ad budget to counter-balance higher warranty costs.
Advertising Age, August 15, 2007
Guardsman rejects warranty claim on mattress stain because it looked older than five days.
WFTS-TV Tampa, August 15, 2007
MaximTrak adds Universal Warranty Corp. to its F&I Menu System for auto dealers.
Press Release, August 15, 2007
SigmaQuest names Mark Anapolsky head of North America sales.
Press Release, August 15, 2007
Pure H2O opens Installation, Service and Warranty Division for residential water treatment units.
Press Release, August 15, 2007
Univ. of Michigan's American Customer Satisfaction Index is up only 1 percent in the last year.
Press Release, August 14, 2007
Chinese-made Meiya debuts in South Africa with a one-year unlimited mileage warranty.
Car Today, August 14, 2007
2008 Lamborghini Murciélago LP640 gets a three-year, unlimited mileage warranty.
What Car? August 14, 2007
Marianne Grant of Snap-on Business Solutions among AIAG Outstanding Achievement Award recipients.
Press Release, August 13, 2007
Microsoft executive sold more shares than first thought before Xbox 360 woes disclosed.
MarketWatch, August 13, 2007
SEC probe into Dell's accounting practices turns two years old.
USA Today, August 12, 2007
As appliance warranties shorten, will extended warranties become more appealing to consumers?
CBS News, August 11, 2007
Onex profit soars to $1.29 per share after company buys divisions from GM, Kodak and Aon.
Canadian Press, August 9, 2007
Foreign Tire Sales recalls 255,000 Chinese-made Westlake, Compass and YKS brand tires.
Associated Press, August 9, 2007
Buick, Lexus lead J.D. Power Vehicle Dependability Study, followed by Cadillac, Mercury and Honda.
Press Release, August 9, 2007
CompTIA updates Standard Error Codes developed 20 years ago for PC repair technicians.
Information Week, August 8, 2007
ABB Australia begins selling service contracts for its robotic products.
Press Release, August 8, 2007
IRS rules that vehicle service contracts are insurance contracts for federal tax purposes.
Insurance Tax Bulletin, August 8, 2007 (PDF file)
 

More Warranty Headlines