January 23, 2014
sponsored by Tavant
ISSN 1550-9214         

Computer Warranty Report:

Traditional laptop and hard drive sales are declining, while smartphone and solid state storage sales soar. However, the change in product mix is raising warranty costs for some manufacturers such as Apple.

In some ways, the computer industry is similar to the automotive industry. You have a handful of OEMs that put their brand names on the box, and a wide range of suppliers that make the major components and systems the OEMs sell.

But there are also big differences. In warranty terms, the OEMs are finding that less in more. Specifically, as the form factor shrinks from desk to lap to hand, warranty costs are rising. And as companies such as Apple Inc. turn from computer manufacturers into smartphone makers, they're seeing escalating warranty expense rates.

World's Largest Warranty Provider

During the first nine months of 2013, Apple has paid more claims per month than either General Motors Co. or Ford Motor Co. In fact it's now paying out more than Hewlett-Packard Co. and Dell Inc. combined. Apple may now be the world's largest warranty provider, yet that label has little to do with computer sales. It's all about the smartphone. And so, keep that in mind as you read this computer warranty report: it's no longer about computers.

As in years past, we started out with a list of 24 U.S.-based computer manufacturers and 42 U.S.-based manufacturers of data storage systems. And we started out with their 2003 warranty expense data, collected from their quarterly and annual reports filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

By 2013, the list had shortened considerably. There were only six computer manufacturers and 15 data storage manufacturers left on the list, with most of the rest either acquired or out of business.

The computer OEMs are led by Apple, HP, Dell, and IBM Corp. The leading data storage companies include Seagate Technology plc, Western Digital Corp., EMC Corp., NetApp Inc., and SanDisk Corp. The dearly departed include Gateway Inc. (acquired by Acer Inc. in 2007), Maxtor Corp. (acquired by Seagate in 2006), Palm Inc. (acquired by HP in 2010), and Storage Technology Corp. & Sun Microsystems Inc. (both now part of Oracle Corp.).

Neither Acer nor Oracle report their warranty expenses publicly, so the claims payments they continue to make are not part of this week's statistics. However, when the other acquisitions were made, the parent companies added their acquisitions' warranty expenses to their own, so they continue to be included in the charts below.

Claims Payments Up Since 2003

In Figure 1, we've tallied the claims payments of the computer OEMs and the data storage companies over the 43 quarters from the start of 2003 until the third quarter of 2013. Note that the quarterly totals remain close to $1.5 billion for most of the period, then begin climbing in 2011.

The quarterly total hit a new record of $2.2 billion in the third quarter of 2013. Normally, that would be a cause for concern, but as we'll detail in a bit, it's almost entirely caused by Apple's success with the iPhone.


Figure 1
U.S. Computer & Data Storage Industries
Warranty Claims Paid, 2003-2013

Figure 1


This may be the last time it makes sense to display a chart for claims paid by the U.S.-based computer industry, for three reasons. First, only 13% of Apple's revenue came from the Macintosh product line in the most recent fiscal year, down from 72% in 2003. Almost 75% came from sales of the iPhone, iPad or iPod.

Second, Dell went private in October, so the financial report we're counting for the third quarter -- from its second fiscal quarter ended August 2, 2013 -- will be the last we'll ever see. Going forward, Dell will no longer report its financials to the SEC, so we won't know its warranty expenses for the rest of calendar 2013.

Third, not only Acer and Oracle don't report. Neither do Asus, Lenovo or Toshiba. Sony and Panasonic report their warranty expenses annually, but those are mixed in with consumer electronics and other product lines. So by default, the list of leading U.S.-based computer manufacturers will soon be reduced down to just HP and IBM.

Accruals Rise Because of Smartphones

The warranty accrual figures show a similar spike in recent quarters, which again we attribute to Apple and its iPhone. With this warranty metric the peak came in the first calendar quarter of 2013, when computer OEMs and data storage providers accrued more than $2.5 billion in warranty expenses.

However, more than $1.5 billion of that came from Apple alone. And it's the culprit in other quarters as well. Its accrual during the months of October-December 2012 topped $1.35 billion, and its accrual during the months of July-September 2013 neared $1.4 billion. So Apple is now accounting for between half and two-thirds of the accruals in the entire industry, up from only 11% at the end of 2009.


Figure 2
U.S. Computer & Data Storage Industries
Warranty Accruals Made, 2003-2013

Figure 2


It's even moving the average expense rates. In Figure 3, we see an industry that had gradually reduced the percentage of revenue it spends on warranty expenses, from around four percent in early 2003 to around two percent in 2012. But then along comes the iPhone -- as fragile as a China doll -- with regulators in multiple countries insisting on two-year warranties. Sales rise, costs rise, and warranty expense rates stopped declining and changed direction.

Less Reliable Replacements?

Both the OEMs' claims and accrual rates have now been above 2.4% for four consecutive quarters. That's not the highest they've ever been. But it is a change of direction, and we're blaming it on the smartphone. Desktops and laptops are more reliable and need less warranty work than before. Smartphones are less reliable and need more warranty work than the dumb phones they replaced.

The data storage manufacturers, meanwhile, seem to have been able to both lengthen the duration of their warranties and reduce the percentage of revenue they spend on them. Expense rates were in the 1.7% to 2.7% range in 2003. So far in 2013 they've been in the range of 1.1% to 1.5%.


Figure 3
U.S. Computer & Data Storage Industries
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2003-2013)

Figure 3


Basically, the percentages in Figure 3 are derived by dividing the expense totals in Figures 1 & 2 by the corresponding sales figures (not shown). The reason the expense totals can remain steady while the percentages drop is because sales rise in the interim. The reason why the expenses can rise quickly but the percentages don't is because sales are rising faster than warranty costs.

Therefore, although iPhone warranty costs are driving up Apple's expenses and Apple is driving up the industry's, the real story is about soaring sales, not manufacturing problems or increased defects. Apple's hardware sales were up 7% last year. Dell's hardware sales were up 3% for the quarter ending in August. However, HP's hardware sales fell 9% and IBM's hardware sales fell 15% in the first nine months of the year. So again, the story is all about Apple -- all about smartphone sales. The traditional computer industry isn't doing so well.

Warranty Reserves Rise

In Figure 4, we're adding all the accruals and subtracting all the claims, and measuring the resulting balance left in the warranty reserve funds of all the industry players. With claims and accruals, there's a 90/10 ratio between the computer OEMs and the data storage folks. With reserves, it's more like an 85/15 ratio. But it's still very heavily weighted towards the OEMs.


Figure 4
U.S. Computer & Data Storage Industries
Warranty Reserves Held, 2003-2013

Figure 4


The computer and data storage companies had a record balance of nearly $7.3 billion in their warranty reserve funds as of the end of March 2013. The balance dipped below $7 billion in the second quarter and rose back above $7.1 billion in the third quarter. But again, it's all Apple. The company accounted for 11% of all industry reserves at the end of 2009. By 2013, its share was well over 40%.

So let's take a closer look at Apple. Figure 5 shows just how recently and just how seriously the company's warranty expense rates soared. From 2007 until the end of 2012, most of its expense rates were measured between one and two percent. But in the first calendar quarter of 2013, Apple raised its accrual rate to 3.9%, and its claims rate rose above two percent for the first time since 2006.


Figure 5
Apple Inc.
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2003-2013)

Figure 5


And of course, sales of iPhones and iPads are also soaring at the same time. The iPhone accounted for $123 million in sales in fiscal 2007. By 2010, the iPhone and iPad together brought in $30.1 billion. In the most recent fiscal year, ended Sept. 30, 2013, their combined sales were up to $123 billion -- a thousand-fold increase in six years!

Then again, let's not get carried away here. The rise in warranty expense rates, while dramatic, is only an increase to a new range of 2.5% to 3.5%. That's where HP, Dell and IBM already are. So really, what Figure 5 is illustrating is the modestly upward effect the change in Apple's product mix is having on warranty expense rates as it becomes a hand-held equipment manufacturer.

For some handheld manufacturers, the more they make the more money they lose, as warranty costs soar out of control. For instance, the year before HP acquired Palm Inc., the small company's claims rate rose above 17%. Research In Motion Ltd. now has a claims rate above seven percent. So Apple at 2.5% to 3.5% is hardly cause for alarm.

Farewell to Dell

Speaking of small changes, in Figure 6, there's been no real news in Dell's warranty expense rates in seven or eight years. But as we mentioned, this represents a farewell of sorts to the company's public data. From this point on, we will have to estimate the company's warranty spending, based on an established range of two to three percent that has persisted since at least 2006.


Figure 6
Dell Inc.
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2003-2013)

Figure 6


In Figure 3, the gap between the claims and accrual rates of the computer OEMs and the data storage companies has remained close to 1.2% or 1.3%. In fact, in early 2005 they almost touched. So the difference between them has never been as great as can be seen in the automotive industry (the subject of the January 9 newsletter).

Widening the Gap?

However, while in the automotive industry the gap is narrowing, as the OEMs find ways to shift more of their net warranty costs onto their suppliers, here it is doing the opposite. In the last four quarters, the gap has averaged 1.5% or 1.6%.

The reason, we believe, is because of changes in data storage technology. The storage systems going into smartphones aren't your traditional hard drives made by the traditional market leaders. And the traditional computer market segment that uses those traditional hard drives isn't doing too well. So you see a divergence between the OEMs and the data storage companies in terms of warranty expense rates.

In Figure 7, the data storage market leader has seen its claims rates remain close to two percent for more than four years while its accrual rate remains below 1.5%. In fact, the 1.7% claims rate that Seagate turned in for the third quarter of 2013 was its lowest since early 2006. And in early 2012 its accrual rate dipped below one percent for the first and only time. Compared to 2008 and 2009, Seagate looks to be in really good shape.


Figure 7
Seagate Technology plc
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2003-2013)

Figure 7


The fact that expense rates are low is all the more impressive given the slowdown that's also affecting the disk drive makers. Seagate's third quarter sales total was down 7% from 2012's level. Western Digital was down 6% from a year ago. EMC and NetApp, which are less about making components and more about selling systems, saw sales go up a bit. But in general, sales for the traditional data storage market leaders, as well as for the traditional computer OEMs, is declining.

In Figure 8, we see the same thing: declining warranty expense rates in spite of declining sales volumes. Western Digital's latest claims rate of 1.3% is its lowest since late 2009. Its 1.1% accrual rate is the lowest it's ever been. And if sales are declining yet expense rates are also declining, that means warranty costs are falling meaningfully thanks to quality improvements.


Figure 8
Western Digital Corp.
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2003-2013)

Figure 8


So there are really two trends to be seen in the data. First, the shift towards the smartphone is increasing warranty costs because the smaller size makes the units more breakable. Second, while the traditional laptop, desktop and hard drive makers are seeing modest sales declines, they're also cutting warranty costs by making a better product.

Solid State Technology

There are some exceptions to those rules, however. SanDisk, with its new solid state data storage technology, saw sales soar 37% in the third quarter. And despite the jump in sales, it's keeping its warranty expense rates more or less level and close to 0.5%. In Figure 9, SanDisk's warranty expense record is a bit more chaotic and changeable than either Seagate's or Western Digital's, but it's also kept both its claims and accrual rates below one percent in 34 of the past 43 quarters.


Figure 9
SanDisk Corp.
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2003-2013)

Figure 9


Does this mean solid state storage technology is less costly in warranty terms? It's too soon to tell. And it may be unfair to compare the technologies, given the difference in price per gigabyte. Seagate, for instance, sells an external terabyte hard drive system for about $90 retail. That's about the same price as SanDisk's 128 GB flash drives.

Warranty Cost per Terabyte?

For argument's sake, let's say Seagate's warranty expense rate is around 2.0%, or around $1.80 per terabyte. And let's say SanDisk's USB flash drives are on sale for $70 each. It would still take eight of them to equal a terabyte. So that's $560 in product cost. Even if the expense rate is only 0.5%, that's still $2.80 per terabyte.

For a more apples-to-apples comparison, the first terabyte flash drives went on sale last year at prices around $1,400 apiece. If such a unit had an 0.5% claims rate, it would cost $7.00 per unit -- almost four times as much as a hard drive of similar capacity. So how should we make the comparison: dollars vs. dollars or cost per unit of capacity?

There are numerous additional contributing factors such as size, power requirements, the number of moving parts, friction, heat, and noise that determine what type of technology is best in any given situation. Clearly, there are good reasons why most laptops use traditional hard drive technology while most smartphones use solid state storage.

But all that's beside the point anyway. The change in storage technology is not the reason behind the higher warranty costs seen in handhelds. That's why the gap in Figure 3 is widening. And that's why SanDisk is seeing relatively stable warranty expense rates, while Apple is not.

Tavant

 

This Week’s Warranty Week Headlines

The Warranty Group celebrates 50 years in business.
Press Release, January 23, 2014
Insurance companies in India look at the smartphone insurance segment.
Business Standard, January 23, 2014
Damage to South Bend's Century Center pavilion covered under warranty.
WSJV-TV Elkhart IN, January 23, 2014
New Leaf Service Contracts licenses PCMI's PCRS platform.
Press Release, January 22, 2014
Who offers the best car warranty in the UK?
The Telegraph (UK), January 21, 2014
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Mize Warranty Connect

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Tire expert suggests negotiating the price of a road hazard warranty.
WFTS-TV Tampa, January 21, 2014
King Koil moves to 10-year replacement warranties.
Furniture Today, January 20, 2014
Driverz Edge president Robert William Roback allegedly embezzled extended warranty premiums.
Las Vegas Sun, January 17, 2014
Driverz Edge president accused in $859,000 insurance scheme.
KTNV-TV Las Vegas, January 17, 2014
Credit cards and home equipment breakdown coverage: alternatives to extended warranties.
Toronto Star, January 17, 2014
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Warranty Chain Management Conference

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Security Coverage launches Tech Home service plans for ISPs to sell.
Press Release, January 16, 2014
Curtis International freezer warranty makes buyer pay freight charges.
KING-TV Seattle (video), January 16, 2014
Tempur Sealy International plans 10-year mattress warranties.
Furniture Today, January 16, 2014
Security Coverage launches Tech Home service plans for ISPs to sell.
Press Release, January 16, 2014
Alberta's New Home Buyer Protection Act takes effect Feb. 1.
Calgary Sun, January 15, 2014
 

More Warranty Headlines below



PCMI - Your technology partner

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Warranty Direct Ltd. rejects auto air conditioner claim, then reconsiders.
What Car?, January 15, 2014
Extended Warranty conference scheduled for Sept. 16-17, 2014 in Nashville.
Press Release, January 15, 2014
American Water Resources offers service contracts in Charlotte NC.
WSOC-TV Charlotte NC, January 14, 2014
The Warranty Group and Safe-Guard Products International renew underwriting deal.
Press Release, January 14, 2014
New Jersey bill could increase warranty work costs in state.
Newark Star-Ledger, January 13, 2014
 

More Warranty Headlines below



After Warranty Analytics

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Don Bonano joins American Auto Guardian as Eastern Regional Vice President.
Press Release, January 13, 2014
BMW announces 5-year/100,000-km warranty for New Zealand.
National Business Review, January 13, 2014
Haier extends the warranty on its air conditioners from 3 years to 5 in Thailand.
The Nation, January 10, 2014
Kentucky bill mandates new parts be used in car wreck repairs made under warranty.
Land Line Magazine, January 10, 2014
The Warranty Group denies burned-out dishwasher claim, then reconsiders.
The Guardian, January 10, 2014
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Sign up for a free subscription to Warranty Week:
     subscribe     change of address     unsubscribe


 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Asus increases product warranty period to 24 months in Nigeria.
All Africa Global Media, January 9, 2014
Expert suggests negotiating the price of a road hazard warranty.
WCPO-TV Cincinnati, January 9, 2014
Aberdeen Group launches research survey on trends in field service.
Press Release, January 9, 2014
International Space Station gets warranty extension to 2024
Planetary Society, January 9, 2014
New Leaf Service Contracts experiences triple digit growth.
Press Release, January 9, 2014
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Entigo, Founding Sponsor

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Global Warranty Group to provide service contract programs to SYMBITS.
Press Release, January 9, 2014
Overview of China's new 3Rs-warranty policy for domestic-use automobiles.
Miller Canfield, January 9, 2014
Honda launches 5-year extended warranties in the UK.
What Car?, January 8, 2014
UK Warranty joint venture adds Nicola Sumner and Jon Negri to its board.
Yorkshire Post, January 4, 2014
Home warranties offer peace of mind.
Bucks County Courier Times, January 3, 2014
American Home Shield wins Best in Service Award from consumer review site.
Press Release, January 3, 2014
HomeWarrantyReviews.com announces Home Warranty Awards for 2013.
Press Release, January 3, 2014
McCusker & Co. to administer automotive furniture protection plans for Ultrashield.
Press Release, January 2, 2014
The Warranty Group signs multi-year service contract agreement with Micro Center.
Press Release, January 2, 2014
Roof warranties explained.
Waterloo (ON) Record, January 1, 2014
Fiat North America to acquire remaining 41% of Chrysler Group shares.
Press Release, January 1, 2014
Do you need an extended warranty? Here are the facts.
Press Release, December 29, 2013
Keep detailed records of warranty claims.
Fox Business, December 28, 2013
Should you register that holiday gift you just received?
ABC News, December 28, 2013
Product-registration cards aren't always needed for warranty coverage.
Consumer Reports, December 26, 2013
Centurion Boats lengthens warranties from one to five years.
Press Release, December 24, 2013
What your manufacturer's warranty doesn't cover.
Macworld, December 24, 2013
Why Honda is a warranty wonder.
The Telegraph (UK), December 23, 2013
UK retailer John Lewis offers iPad Air with free 3-year warranty.
Trusted Reviews, December 21, 2013
Navistar net loss nearly equals additional warranty accrual.
Press Release, December 20, 2013
Six UK retailers mislead customers over return rights for faulty goods.
Moneywise magazine, December 19, 2013
When you should (and shouldn't) buy an extended warranty.
U.S. News & World Report, December 19, 2013
Ferroli Modena HE boiler now available with 7-year warranty.
Press Release, December 18, 2013
Ascent Resources to pay Global Power Sources in stock for warranty claim cost.
Alliance News, December 18, 2013
Apple agrees to two-year warranties in Australia after ACCC wrist slap.
CRN, December 18, 2013
Ceiling fan had lifetime warranty but Sears doesn't sell them anymore.
Boston Globe, December 17, 2013
Jabil sells its electronics warranty repair business to iQor Holdings for $725m.
Press Release, December 17, 2013
SquareTrade says Washington DC residents are clumsiest tech users in the U.S.
Press Release, December 16, 2013
Tire warranty: So simple, yet so complicated?
Bangor (ME) Daily News, December 16, 2013
Sandra Finn of Cross Country Home Services gets Bronze Stevie Award.
South Florida Sun-Sentinel, December 16, 2013
Why buying a long warranty is just a waste of money.
Daily Mail (UK), December 14, 2013
Consumers in Manitoba advised to know their rights about warranties & returns.
Press Release, December 13, 2013
Extended warranties for your gadgets: Are they worth the money?
AOL Daily Finance, December 13, 2013
Intercontinental Warranty Services develops new website.
Press Release, December 12, 2013
AmTrust stock declines after GeoInvesting challenges accounting.
Bloomberg News, December 12, 2013
AmTrust Financial Services reports strong financial outlook.
Press Release, December 12, 2013
Just say no to gadget protection.
Associated Press, December 12, 2013
Why extended warranties may be a good deal after all.
NBC News, December 12, 2013
NY attorney general asks wireless carriers about rejecting anti-theft technology.
Press Release, December 11, 2013
New home warranty law in Alberta inadequate, critics say.
Calgary Herald, December 11, 2013
Brown & Brown purchases assets of O'Neil Financial Services Agency.
Press Release, December 11, 2013
Hyundai drops arbitration clause in warranty disputes.
Consumer Affairs, December 11, 2013
Securranty details new iPhone, iPad protection plans.
Dealerscope, December 10, 2013
Autoplex Extended Services faces more than 100 BBB complaints.
KMOV-TV St. Louis, December 10, 2013
Air Tractor announces new airframe & engine warranty.
Press Release, December 10, 2013
The impact of Ford's lengthening of its Service Parts Warranty to 24 months.
Press Release, December 10, 2013
Enphase: Anemic revenue growth with alarming warranty obligation growth.
Seeking Alpha, December 10, 2013
Product warranty, Samsung style.
Fortune, December 10, 2013
Harvey Normans fined AU$116,000 over dodgy warranty support.
CRN Australia, December 9, 2013
PC laptops and accidental damage: Best and worst warranties (updated).
ZDNet, December 7, 2013
Toyo Tire U.S.A. Corp. improves its warranty policies.
Press Release, December 5, 2013
Choice Home Warranty accused of not paying claims.
WMAQ-TV Chicago, December 5, 2013
Global Warranty Group to provide handset protection in 325 Z Wireless retail locations.
Press Release, December 5, 2013
Dutch regulator ACM wants better information on mobile phone guarantees.
Telecom Paper, December 5, 2013
JM Eagle to appeal loss of whistleblower court case over pipe failures.
Plastics News, December 4, 2013
 

More Warranty Headlines