June 4, 2015
sponsored by Tavant
ISSN 1550-9214         

Home Appliance & HVAC Warranty Report:

There are a few very large companies with operations in multiple industries that make it difficult to examine just the warranty expenses of the major appliance and HVAC companies. But if we set them off on their own, we can calculate industry averages for the expenses of others.

The makers of home appliances and HVAC systems, like those in the automotive, computing, and aerospace businesses, are part of a very warranty-intensive industry. But while there's a lot of money involved in the claims and accruals, the industry's warranty expenses are not excessively high as a percentage of revenue.

To reach this week's conclusion, we began with a list of 39 U.S.-based home appliance manufacturers, and a list of 39 makers of heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems. All 78 companies were on one list or the other, but none were on both lists (although Ingersoll-Rand could be either or both, thanks to its Thermo King truck refrigeration appliances and its Trane and American Standard HVAC brands).

The leading appliance makers included General Electric Co.; Ingersoll-Rand; Jarden Corp.; Manitowoc Company Inc.; and Whirlpool Corp. The leading HVAC manufacturers included A.O. Smith Corp.; Emerson Electric Co.; Honeywell International Inc.; Johnson Controls Inc.; and United Technologies Corp. (the owner of Carrier).

Spread Across Multiple Industries

The biggest problem with these groups is the overlap the membership has with other industries such as aerospace, automotive, power generation, medical equipment, telecommunications, and consumer electronics. And unfortunately, the biggest warranty providers in each group are also among the largest warranty providers in some of those other industries: besides appliances, GE makes turbines, jet engines and medical equipment, while units of the United Technologies conglomerate make jet engines, helicopters, avionics, and elevators.

Left untreated, the totals and averages for the HVAC and appliance groups would have largely mirrored the totals and averages for just United Technologies and GE by themselves. So what we've done in the charts below is to make those two companies separate from the rest.

In Figure 1, the annual claims payments of the 38 HVAC companies and UTC/Carrier are detailed, as are the annual claims payments of the 38 appliance companies plus GE. Readers therefore can make assumptions about how much of UTC's total worldwide claims payments arise from Carrier, and how much of GE's total comes from appliances (which by the way are being sold to Electrolux soon).

Figure 1
Worldwide Warranty Claims of
U.S.-based Home Appliance & HVAC Makers
(claims paid in US$ millions, 2003-2014)

Figure 1

In 2014, all 78 companies paid out about $2.9 billion in claims worldwide, which was about $79 million less than they did in 2013. GE saw claims fall by $100 million but UTC saw claims rise by $57 million. And then there were relatively small declines in claims paid by the other HVAC and appliance companies.

In fact, once GE and UTC/Carrier are set off by themselves, one of the most distinctive features of the rest of the HVAC and appliance claims data is how steady the annual totals of the others have been. There's really not much change from year to year, and that's true for all of their warranty metrics, not just claims payments.

Also, compared to automotive and homebuilding, there's really no deep trench in this group's data to mark the recession. Sure, their peak years may have come before the Lehman Brothers panic, but there's nothing like the cyclical downturns we saw in the car & truck warranty data or in the new home & RV warranty data.

Among the companies that cut their claims payments the most in terms of dollars are Johnson Controls Inc. (owners of York International), Honeywell, Whirlpool, and Ingersoll-Rand. Those that saw the biggest increases included Keurig Green Mountain Inc., Helen of Troy Ltd., and Emerson Electric Co. However, on a proportional basis, one of the biggest reductions was seen at Rockwell Automation Inc., while one of the biggest increases was seen at Nortek Inc.

Warranty Accruals

It's much the same story with warranty accruals. The peak for the entire group of 78 companies came in 2008, as it did for GE and the other appliance companies. And the peak in accruals for just UTC and the HVAC companies came a bit earlier, in 2006.

But last year, the appliance companies raised their accruals by $76 million, while the HVAC companies raised their accruals by $29 million. UTC/Carrier raised their accruals by $24 million. So it was a big cut by GE that drove down the overall total from $2.95 billion in 2013 to $2.93 billion in 2014.

Figure 2
Worldwide Warranty Accruals of
U.S.-based Home Appliance & HVAC Makers
(accruals made in US$ millions, 2003-2014)

Figure 2

It was the third year in a row that warranty accruals in the HVAC/appliance total have been below $3 billion, after six years above that mark. But accruals are still above the levels seen in 2003-2005.

GE made the biggest reduction in accruals by far. In fact, only five other large HVAC or appliance companies made any reductions at all in their accruals: A.O. Smith, Emerson Electric, Jarden, Nortek, and Rockwell Automation. Accrual increases were much more common.

The largest accrual increases, in dollar terms, were seen at Helen of Troy, Honeywell, Ingersoll-Rand, Keurig, United Technologies, and Whirlpool. In relative terms, Helen of Troy was the largest, with accruals jumping from $33 million in 2013 to $54 million in 2014, followed by Keurig, which raised its accruals from $20 to $31 million.

And because of its size, GE's mammoth $152 cut in warranty accruals amounted to only a 20% reduction. However, on a relative basis, none of the other accrual reductions were even half as big. That's the main reason we decided to put GE and UTC on their own: the sheer size of their warranty operations makes even their small changes bigger than the biggest changes of the others.

Warranty Reserves

In Figure 3, we're adding together the year-ending balances of the warranty reserve funds of the 78 HVAC and appliance companies from 2003 to 2014. What immediately becomes apparent is that their peak balance came at the end of 2011, when they held a collective $5.87 billion in their warranty reserves. In 2014 they dipped a bit below $5 billion -- their first time doing so since 2005.

Figure 3
Worldwide Warranty Reserves of
U.S.-based Home Appliance & HVAC Makers
(reserves held in US$ millions, 2003-2014)

Figure 3

Their collective balances fell by $72 million last year. But again, the biggest of the big set the pace. UTC/Carrier's reserve balance fell by $47 million, and GE's fell by $125 million. The other 38 HVAC companies raised their balances by $46 million, and the other 38 appliance companies raised their balances by $53 million.

It was the third consecutive year in which the industry's warranty reserves fell. Besides GE and UTC, other large companies allowing their reserves to fall included Manitowoc, Honeywell, Emerson, and Nortek. Those allowing their balances to rise included Ingersoll-Rand, Johnson Controls, Lennox International Inc., Masco Corp., and Whirlpool. On a relative basis, Keurig let its reserves grow by more than half, and National Presto Industries Inc. let its reserves fall by more than a third of its 2013-ending balance.

Warranty Expense Rates

In Figures 4 through 7, we've taken the claims and accrual data in Figures 1 and 2 and recalculated the expense totals as a percentage of product sales revenue. In that way, the data is adapted to account for changes in sales, which can help to identify the reasons behind some of the increases and decreases noted above.

In Figure 4, we're tracking just the 38 appliance manufacturers besides GE. At the end of 2014, they were spending a little under 1.3% of their product revenue on warranty claims, while setting aside a little over 1.3% of their sales as warranty accruals. Taking their $822 million claims total from Figure 1 and their $901 million accrual total from Figure 2 and working backwards implies total product sales of around $65.8 billion.

Obviously, this is much larger than the U.S. appliance market in 2014, even when measured at retail prices. However, keep in mind that it also includes exports by U.S.-based manufacturers, and it also includes sales of other products by companies that cross industries.

With that in mind, it appears that an expense rate of 1.3% is on the low side of where the industry has been for most of the past 12 years. Expense rates were generally lower than that back in 2003 and 2004, and were generally higher than 1.3% from 2005 to 2010. But that's about where they've been since 2011, give or take a bit for some seasonal oscillations.

Figure 4
All U.S.-based Appliance Makers (except GE)
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of sales revenue, 2003-2014)

Figure 4

Helen of Troy was the only appliance maker to see its 2014 expense rates rise by enough to earn it a spot on the top 10 lists included in the March 12 newsletter. GE was the only appliance company to see its expense rates fall by enough to get it onto a top 10 list (see Figure 5).

Others that cut their claims rates significantly include Middleby Corp. and Ingersoll-Rand. Others that cut their accrual rates significantly include Jarden. Besides Helen of Troy, the only other major appliance company to see both of their warranty expense rates rise significantly last year was Keurig, the coffee maker manufacturer.

GE's Revenue Segmentation

In Figure 5, we've charted GE on its own. However, we have to explain a significant change we made in the way these expense rates are figured. In 2003 and 2004, GE said its warranty expenditures arose primarily from its GE Energy product line. But in 2005, it said the expenses were related primarily to the GE Infrastructure and GE Healthcare product lines.

This had the effect of changing not the size of the expense, but the size of the sales to which the expenses were compared. In 2004, GE Energy reported $17.3 billion in revenue. In 2005, GE Infrastructure, of which GE Energy was part, reported $41.8 billion in revenue. And GE Healthcare reported an additional $15.15 billion in revenue.

Previously, we compared GE's 2003 and 2004 warranty expenses to just GE Energy's revenue, calculating warranty expense rates between 4% and 5%. These, we believe, are close to the true figures for GE's warranted product lines.

However, in 2005 and afterwards, we were forced to compare GE Infrastructure's and GE Healthcare's much larger revenue base to the company's warranty expenses, which dropped the expense rates down to roughly one percent. It was partially caused by a decline in the size of the top of the fraction, as can be seen in Figures 1 and 2. But it was caused more by a massive increase in the size of the bottom of the fraction -- caused merely by the way GE reshuffled the segmenting of its business units in 2005.

Therefore, what we've done in Figure 5 is to refigure the 2003 and 2004 expense rates by dividing them by the same misleadingly larger segment of GE's total revenue as is used in the post-2005 figures, even though the company said those expenses arose primarily from GE Energy. But that just goes to show how misleading it would be to include GE in the appliance group: Even the company itself says most of its warranty expenses originate from products that belong in other industries.

Figure 5
General Electric Co.
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of sales revenue, 2003-2014)

Figure 5

This change in the way we calculate GE's warranty expense rates makes it easier to see the generally downward trend the company has enjoyed over the past 12 years. Only in 2011 did expense rates rise significantly. And in the three years since, they've continued to fall. In 2014, the company's warranty expense rates were a little above and a little below 0.6%, which is significantly lower than the rest of the appliance makers.

However, also note that while the data in Figure 4 is charted in the form of 48 quarterly pairs of expense rates, the data in Figure 5 comes in the form of 48 pairs of annual data. That's because GE discloses its warranty expenses only once a year in its annual report, while most of the other appliance companies report their expenses quarterly.

Declining Expense Rates

In Figure 6, we're tracking the warranty expense rates of just United Technologies Corp., which again shows a decidedly downward trend over the past 12 years. In fact, except for a few bumps and excursions in 2003, 2008 and 2011, it's almost a straight line down from the 2.3% level to the most recent 0.7% level.

Figure 6
United Technologies Corp. (including Carrier)
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of sales revenue, 2003-2014)

Figure 6

The problem is, UTC provides just one set of worldwide warranty expense figures, so we have no way of knowing how much of it is HVAC, how much is aerospace, and how much is other products such as elevators or security/safety equipment.

Only about 26% of UTC's consolidated total revenue comes from the climate control and security business unit, which includes Carrier's HVAC systems. And that business unit includes not just Carrier, but also security products such as intruder alarms, access control systems, and video surveillance systems, as well as a wide range of fire safety products such as hazard detection and fixed suppression products, portable fire extinguishers, fire detection systems, and other safety systems.

Therefore, it's entirely possible that the aerospace product line is cutting its warranty expense rates and is entirely responsible for the good news seen in Figure 6. And it's entirely possible that Carrier is doing all the cost-cutting. We know the segmentation of the company's revenue, but not its warranty expenses. So in order to guess how much warranty expense comes from HVAC products, we would first have to figure out what the industry average might be.

HVAC Industry Average

In Figure 7, we've taken the warranty expenses of 38 other HVAC companies besides UTC/Carrier, and divided them by product sales totals. Unlike Figures 5 and 6, there's no downward trend here. In fact, all the data lies between 0.6% and 1.1%, which isn't really much of a range.

Figure 7
All U.S.-based HVAC Manufacturers (except Carrier)
Average Warranty Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of sales revenue, 2003-2014)

Figure 7

The long-term average is just below 0.8%. The 2014 average is closer to 0.75%. In other words, in order to generate a little over $1 billion in warranty claims and an average claims rate of roughly 0.75%, product sales would have to be in the vicinity of $146 billion a year.

If we assume that UTC's Climate, Controls & Security business unit generates warranty expenses at roughly the same 0.8% rate as the rest of the HVAC industry, then its warranty claims and accrual totals are likely to be around $132 million per year. If this were so, then the business unit would account for 38% to 40% of UTC's total warranty expenses, far above their share of total revenue.

In other words, while HVAC equipment has a generally low level of warranty expense rates, it's not as low as what we've seen in the aerospace industry (covered in the April 2 newsletter) or in the medical equipment industry (covered in the April 30 newsletter).

And although our estimates are loaded with assumptions, we'd suggest that the HVAC and appliance businesses at both UTC and GE account for a larger share of warranty expenses than revenue. We can only hope that when GE Appliances transfers over to Electrolux, one or both parties will make some financial disclosures that verify this hunch.



This Week’s Warranty Week Headlines

AmTrust Financial Services gets "Strong Buy" rating from Zacks Investment Research.
The Legacy, June 4, 2015
Thor Industries sees lower warranty costs and higher gross profit margins.
Press Release, June 4, 2015
Navistar keeps warranty expenses low, reduces net losses.
Press Release, June 4, 2015
Frost & Sullivan report says big data can help truck makers reduce warranty costs.
Press Release, June 4, 2015
M.D.C. Holdings subsidiary wins award for customer satisfaction and warranty services.
Press Release, June 4, 2015

More Warranty Headlines below

Mize Warranty Connect


Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Great Falls community reacts to news of Asurion call center closure.
Great Falls (MT) Tribune, June 3, 2015
Former GM CEO Rick Wagoner to be questions about recall delay on Sept. 2.
Detroit News, June 3, 2015
Pennsylvania files suit against Guardian Web Co. and others over service contract refunds.
Press Release, June 3, 2015
GWC Warranty hosts Elite Dealer Council meeting at its headquarters.
Auto Remarketing, June 3, 2015
Why just sell a jet when you can also sell service contracts?
Toronto Globe and Mail, June 2, 2015

More Warranty Headlines below

PCMI - Your technology partner


Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

AUL Corp. unveils Absolute suite of vehicle service contract products.
Press Release, June 2, 2015
HomeLife Warranty Protection agrees to use Home One Warranty software.
Press Release, June 2, 2015
Sewer Line Warranties of America pays Dallas a $450,000 brand license fee.
KXAS-TV Dallas, June 2, 2015
Unhappy home buyers complain about Tarion Warranty's compensation tribunals.
Toronto Star, June 2, 2015
Chrysler powertrain warranty reduction could help sell extended warranties.
Automotive News, June 1, 2015

More Warranty Headlines below

After Warranty Analytics


Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Chrysler cuts U.S. powertrain warranty from 100,000 miles to 60,000 miles.
Car and Driver, May 28, 2015
Dealer explains the real value of buying an extended warranty for an RV.
Press Release, May 28, 2015
Mechanical breakdown insurance costs and benefits compared.
Stuff (New Zealand), May 27, 2015
Service Contract Industry Council reminds consumers of the benefits of a vehicle service contract.
Press Release, May 26, 2015
CNH Industrial's Saskatoon plant cuts warranty claims by 90% on major products.
Press Release, May 26, 2015

More Warranty Headlines below

Sign up for a free subscription to Warranty Week:
     subscribe     change of address     unsubscribe


Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

FTC affirms consumers' right to go to court over warranty disputes.
The Consumerist, May 26, 2015
NATM Buying Corp. taps New Leaf Service Contracts for extended service program.
This Week in Consumer Electronics, May 26, 2015
Evergreen Underwriting Group renews agreement with McCusker & Company Inc.
Press Release, May 26, 2015
Wooden baseball bats shatter but aluminum bats have 1-year warranties.
Des Moines Register, May 26, 2015
Report pegs global warranty management systems market at US$10.55 billion in 2013.
Press Release, May 25, 2015

More Warranty Headlines below

Entigo, Founding Sponsor


Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

FTC will keep consumer product warranty rules in current form with some modifications.
Press Release, May 22, 2015
A.M. Best affirms the Ally Insurance Group's B++ financial strength rating.
Press Release, May 22, 2015
Solar panel maker Stion adds warranty insurance policy from Munich Re.
Press Release, May 22, 2015
Walmart agrees to tire tread warranty settlement in California.
KXTV-TV Sacramento CA, May 22, 2015
FTC toughens rules barring implied tying of warranties.
Consumer Affairs, May 22, 2015
Mike Anderson, COO of Assurant Solutions, receives Icon Leadership Award.
Press Release, May 21, 2015
Cross Country Home Services appoints Steven E. Upshaw as CEO.
Press Release, May 21, 2015
American Home Shield wins Women's Choice Award for 2015.
Press Release, May 21, 2015
Best Buy sees fewer claims on its mobile warranty plans in first quarter.
Press Release, May 21, 2015
Lumber Liquidators CEO quits amid federal probe into flooring safety.
Wall Street Journal, May 21, 2015
Warranty clerk to serve 30 consecutive weekends in jail over warranty fraud.
Cecil Daily Whig (MD), May 21, 2015
List of companies with the best lifetime warranties.
Go Banking Rates, May 21, 2015
Australia to review the need for lemon laws for autos.
The Motor Report, May 21, 2015
Consumer Electronics Association supports the E-Warranty Act of 2015.
Press Release, May 20, 2015
Takata widens airbag recall to cover 34 million cars worldwide.
Bloomberg News, May 20, 2015
ANV Holdings forms global service contract underwriting unit.
Press Release, May 19, 2015
Warranty accruals at Toyo Chemical Industrial Products cause a net loss.
Tire Business, May 19, 2015
Former car dealership manager arrested for pocketing extended warranty premiums.
Bristol (CT) Press, May 19, 2015
Extended warranties give dealers extra revenue and offer consumers peace of mind.
Automotive Management, May 19, 2015
HomeServe USA settles with Maryland Attorney General, pays $115,000.
Press Release, May 18, 2015
Angie Hicks says remodeling project warranties should last at least a year.
Angie's List, May 18, 2015
Siemens UK & Ireland offers 5-year warranties on Scalance networking gear.
Process & Control Today, May 18, 2015
U.S. Senators Deb Fischer and Bill Nelson introduce S. 1359 - The E-Warranty Act of 2015.
Press Release, May 15, 2015
Who handles the warranty if a company goes out of business?
Lifehacker Australia, May 14, 2015
Artificial turf warranties don't cover melting in the hot sun.
KPHO-TV Phoenix, May 14, 2015
AutoNation-branded vehicle service contracts are backed by the Warranty Group.
Press Release, May 13, 2015
Hidden warranties can help you with costly repairs.
WKMG-TV Orlando FL, May 13, 2015
American Home Shield donates $50,000 to Operation Homefront for veterans.
Press Release, May 13, 2015
A.M. Best affirms financial strength rating of A for Old United Casualty Co.
Press Release, May 13, 2015
Sidney, Ohio launches Service Line Warranty program.
Sidney Daily News, May 13, 2015
Chevrolet Malibu seat belt recall based on 36 warranty claims.
Associated Press, May 12, 2015
Survey finds ethanol is a major factor in boat engine damage.
Boating Industry, May 11, 2015
Deuk Spine Institute offers surgery warranty program.
Space Coast Daily (FL), May 11, 2015
Assurant Inc. increases its quarterlydividend to 30 cents per share
Press Release, May 8, 2015
PrimeTime Lighting lengthens its LED warranty from 2 to 5 years.
Press Release, May 7, 2015
AmTrust Financial Services to acquire Warranty Solutions from Wells Fargo.
Press Release, May 7, 2015
Asurion to close NEW's Great Falls MT call center in August
Great Falls Tribune, May 7, 2015
Lumber Liquidators pulls Chinese-made laminate flooring amid safety concerns.
Wall Street Journal, May 7, 2015
Home Warranties vs. Homeowners Insurance
Realty Biz News, May 7, 2015
Former Best Buy CEO Brian Dunn becomes chairman of Upsie.
Minneapolis / St. Paul Business Journal, May 6, 2015
McGraw Powersports selects PCMI's PCRS system for claims administration.
Press Release, May 5, 2015
Tesla sells certified preowned Model S cars online with 4-year warranties.
Business Insider, May 5, 2015
Itron Inc. blames increased warranty expense for decreased gross margins.
Press Release, May 4, 2015
ReportLinker releases $7,998 study about extended warranties in eight countries.
Press Release, May 4, 2015
Tesla gives Powerwall Home Battery a 10-year warranty.
Detroit Free Press, May 1, 2015
New Leaf Service Contracts & Core Centric Solutions develop online parts order portal.
This Week in Consumer Electronics, May 1, 2015
Hurricane-proof impact windows crack, but that's not covered under warranty.
WPLG-TV Miami, May 1, 2015
Volvo Penta doubles the warranty on parts and accessories from 12 to 24 months.
Trade Only Today, May 1, 2015
Warranty Ninja simplifies warranty registration process with new app.
SE MI Start-up, May 1, 2015
Biolase sees higher warranty expenses due to longer warranties.
Press Release, April 30, 2015
Carcraft collapses in the UK, used car warranties won't be honoured.
Sky News, April 30, 2015
AutoWurld to sell vehicle service contracts administered by Prime Auto Care.
Press Release, April 30, 2015
Iridium Communications sees higher net income and lower warranty costs.
Press Release, April 30, 2015
Fiat Chrysler says higher warranty costs hurt earnings growth.
Press Release, April 29, 2015
America's Preferred Home Warranty launches new real estate portal.
Press Release, April 28, 2015

More Warranty Headlines