July 1, 2021
sponsored by PCMI
ISSN 1550-9214         

Worldwide Jet Engine Warranty Report:

Though some of the biggest manufacturers in the industry are also in many other lines of business, the warranty expense rates of the "pure play" jet engine makers remain close to industry averages. And while COVID grounded many commercial airliners, it didn't decimate the jet engine industry as badly as one might have guessed.

While in last week's newsletter we found out how hard-hit the sale of business jets and commercial jetliners were during the global pandemic, this week we find out to exactly nobody's surprise that the sale of jet engines was hurt as badly.

Boeing's civilian aircraft revenue was down 50% last year and Airbus fell 34%. So it's no shock to discover that three of the "pure play" jet engine manufacturers saw sales declines of 21% to 32%. What's more surprising is to find out their warranty claims didn't fall as fast as sales, or in at least one case, actually rose.

One would expect that in an industry whose customer count fell by 95% at its lowest point in mid-April 2020, the pain would be more evenly distributed. One would expect that planes that spent more time on the ground sitting idle than they did flying nearly empty in the air wouldn't need as much warranty work as they did during normal times. But one would be wrong.

Jet Engine Market Structure

The list of the world's top jet engine manufacturers includes Rolls Royce Holdings plc; GE Aviation, a subsidiary of General Electric Co.; Pratt & Whitney, a subsidiary of Raytheon Technologies Corp. (formerly known as United Technologies Corp.); Safran Aircraft Engines, a division of the Paris-based Safran S.A.; Honeywell Aerospace, a division of Honeywell International Inc.; the Munich-based MTU Aero Engines AG; and privately-held Williams International from Pontiac, Michigan.

There are also several joint ventures amongst and between some of the top industry players. The Engine Alliance is a joint venture between GE Aviation and Pratt & Whitney. CFM International is a joint venture between GE Aviation and Safran Aircraft Engines. Safran also has a joint venture with Boeing Co. to produce auxiliary power units for aircraft.

PowerJet is a joint venture between Safran and UEC-Saturn. International Aero Engines AG, also known as IAE, is a joint venture of Pratt & Whitney, MTU Aero Engines, and Japanese Aero Engine Corp. Rolls Royce and Avio S.p.A. are former IAE shareholders. And Avio in turn was formerly part of Fiat S.p.A. However, those two along with MTU and ITP Aero, a Spanish subsidiary of Rolls-Royce, are also partners in a military aerospace engine consortium called EuroJet Turbo GmbH.

There are several other turbofan manufacturers descended from the Soviet era. And there are also a couple of new manufacturers emerging in China as well. However, there is no publicly available warranty expense data for any of these companies. And their export sales are minimal. Imagine the reaction to a pilot's announcement, "Today we'll be flying at 35,000 feet on a pair of engines made by the Russian government."

A pie chart of jet engine sales for each of these manufacturers and joint ventures would be most helpful. However, it would not aid much in our warranty expense reporting, because none of these diversified manufacturers segment their claims and accruals by product line. Instead, they publish just one set of numbers for all their activities worldwide.

Inevitably, that means we are including warranty expenses for much more than just jet engines when we look at the reports of GE, Raytheon, and Honeywell in particular. However, without getting into conjecture about the rate at which warranty expenses arise in their aviation product lines as opposed to automotive, healthcare, or building trades, we are stuck using the numbers we are given.

Warranty Claims Worldwide

Let's begin with a look at the claims payments reported by the top six jet engine manufacturers over the past five years. Reported claims fell by 7% in 2020 to $1.74 billion, after falling a much steeper -21% in 2018-19. Much of that drop, however, can be traced back to GE's spin-off of Baker Hughes and Raytheon's spin-off of Carrier and Otis Elevator. Because of these spin-offs, their product revenue totals dropped off -43% and -27%, respectively, from 2018 to 2019.

Raytheon saw a big jump in its 2018 claims total, but that metric dropped by a third in 2019 and fell a further -12% last year to $292 million. GE, however, saw its claims costs rise from $715 million in 2019 to $913 million in 2020 -- a steep 28% increase.


Figure 1
Top Jet Engine Makers Worldwide
Claims Paid per Year
(in US$ dollars, 2016-2020)

Figure 1


Claims were down for all the others last year. Starting with the least severe drops, Safran's claims costs fell -3.5% to $219 million; Honeywell's claims fell -4.4% to $172 million; Rolls-Royce's claims fell -15% to $134 million; and MTU's claims fell -32% to $12.6 million. But those declines were not enough to offset GE's rise, so total claims payments rose from $1.63 billion to $1.74 billion.

We should note that each year's claims, accruals, and reserve figures are first converted from euro or pounds sterling into dollars before the annual changes are calculated, so these percentages will also reflect changes in the euro-dollar and pound-dollar exchange rates, in addition to changes in the base amounts.

The biggest difference between claims and accruals is how they behave during an industry downturn. Claims are paid for warranty work on already operating units, so that is a backwards-looking indicator that depends on the size and shape of the installed base. As bad as the downturn was in civil aviation during 2020, it had just a very small effect on the size of the installed base. As far as the shape it was in, many jets were parked and idle, so there was much less wear and tear on their engines.

The thing is, we don't know which of GE's product lines generated the sharp rise in claims last year, and GE doesn't say so in its annual report. We know it wasn't GE Appliances, which was sold off to a Chinese company in mid-2016. And we know it wasn't Baker Hughes, which was divested in 2019. And while we know the pandemic hit GE Capital Aviation Services hard, we also that operation is a leasing service, not a manufacturing operation.

The wind turbine business isn't big enough, and the electrical power equipment business has an overcapacity problem. And so, by a process of elimination, we think the likely culprit is GE Healthcare. And indeed, GE provides a confirmation of sorts in its annual report: "Our healthcare segment experienced increased demand for certain types of products and services, including ventilators, monitoring solutions, x-ray, anesthesia and point-of-care ultrasound product lines, partially offset by decreased demand in other parts of the business as patients have postponed certain procedures and hospitals have deferred spending." Chances are that heavy usage also drove more warranty claims in that segment.

Warranty Accruals Worldwide

The thing about warranty accruals is it's always a forward-looking metric that is closely tied to product sales. When sales rise, accruals rise proportionally, unless there has been some change in reliability or the cost or frequency of repairs. As can be seen in Figure 2, accruals plunged in 2020, thanks primarily to a big decline for Safran. But GE was once again up for the year.


Figure 2
Top Jet Engine Makers Worldwide
Accruals Made per Year
(in US$ dollars, 2016-2020)

Figure 2


It would be easy to once again blame GE Healthcare, but that excuse doesn't hold up when you delve into the numbers. That segment's revenue was actually down 10% to $18 billion. And while that wasn't as bad as the -33% plunge in GE Aviation revenue last year, it doesn't explain GE's +11% rise in accruals to $788 million. If sales fell, accruals should have followed, unless there was a change in reliability or the cost or frequency of repairs. So this supports the heavy usage theory.

At Raytheon, product revenue was up 31% yet warranty accruals were down 30%. That makes no sense. For the others, the accrual numbers did move in the general direction of sales, however. Honeywell saw a 10% drop in sales and a 5% drop in accruals. Safran saw a 32% drop in sales and a 57% drop in accruals. Rolls-Royce saw a 21% drop in sales and a 26% drop in accruals. And MTU reported a 30% drop in sales and a 49% drop in accruals.

Warranty Expense Rates

The industry total ended up at $1.68 billion in warranty accruals last year, down a steep 23% from $2.19 billion in 2019. As a percentage of product revenue, accruals fell from 1.5% in 2019 to 1.3% in 2020, which was almost as steep as the dollar totals. The reason for the mismatch is Raytheon's big jump in product revenue, which we think was almost completely on the military side. Commercial aerospace sales actually fell from $33.2 billion in 2019 to $22.1 billion in 2020. And since military sales don't have warranties in the traditional sense, this may give us a false reading of expense rates.

In Figure 3, we're relying on each company's reported totals for claims paid, accruals made, and products sold to calculate a claims rate (claims as a percentage of sales) and an accrual rate (accruals as a percentage of sales). In 2020, the industry's claims rate rose to 1.31% while its average accrual rate fell to 1.27%, so the lines crossed.


Figure 3
Top Jet Engine Makers Worldwide
Average Claims & Accrual Rates
(as a % of product sales, 2016-2020)

Figure 3


Strangely, the escalation of GE's claims and accrual rates due to the inclusion of healthcare and other product lines, and the undercount of Raytheon's claims and accrual rates due to the inclusion of military product sales, seem to counteract each other. GE's claims and accrual rates read 2.4% and 2.1%, respectively, at the end of 2020, and that's clearly much higher than the industry average for jet engines. Raytheon's 2020 readings are 0.7% and 0.7%, respectively, and those are clearly too low. Honeywell, another diversified company, reported equally low readings of 0.7% and 0.7% in 2020.

However, Safran, which is more of a pure play in aviation, reported claims and accrual rates of 1.2% and 1.5% -- just under and just over the industry averages. Rolls-Royce, which despite its name is not a car company (that luxury nameplate is now owned by BMW), is almost a pure play in jet engines, and its warranty expense rates were 1.8% and 1.6% in 2020. MTU was at 1.0% and 1.3%.

Safran had a bad year in 2018 and Rolls-Royce had a bad year in 2017. But in both 2019 and 2020, they along with MTU were relatively close to the industry-average claims and accrual rates. So perhaps their baselines are the ones we should pay more attention to in the future?

Warranty Reserves Worldwide

One big change from the jet engine warranty report we published last summer in the August 13 newsletter is the restatement of Raytheon's 2019 warranty reserve total. At the time, it was only four months since United Technologies had merged with Raytheon and spun off Carrier and Otis, so we didn't yet know all the metrics of the separations.

Now we do, and so in Figure 4, Raytheon has the third-largest warranty reserve fund balance in both 2019 and 2020, of $1.03 and $1.06 billion, respectively. Safran is in second at $1.36 billion and $1.27 billion, respectively. And GE is in first, with $2.16 billion in its reserve at the end of 2019 and $2.05 billion in the fund at the end of 2020.


Figure 4
Top Jet Engine Makers Worldwide
Reserves Held per Year
(in US$ dollars, 2016-2020)

Figure 4


The total for the warranty reserves of these six companies is $5.30 billion in 2019 and $5.07 billion in 2020. Again, for Safran, Rolls-Royce, and MTU, we converted their euro and pounds into dollars to calculate this total, so it also reflects foreign exchange fluctuations from one year to the next.

But there seems to be a consensus on the vector of change. The industry's reserves fell -4.3% in 2020. Rolls-Royce's fell -4.6%, GE's fell -5.1%, and Safran's fell -6.7%. Raytheon was the only one to report an increase, and it was proportionally very small.

And again, we believe the much steeper drop-off in 2019 was due to the reorganizations at GE and Raytheon. For instance, we now know that Carrier and Otis took just over half a billion with them at the time of their spin-offs, while Baker Hughes reported reserves of $236 million in early 2019.

And so, while the GE, Raytheon and Honeywell numbers cover much more than jet engines, the industry averages seem to balance that out. Once again, last year claims were up 7.0% to $1.74 billion, accruals were down 23% to $1.69 billion, and reserves were down 4.3% to $5.07 billion. The industry average claims rate rose to 1.31% while the average accrual rate fell to 1.27%. And that reflected a 6.4% decline in product sales.

Summer Vacation

Next week, and in fact for the next few weeks, the newsletter will be on summer holidays. It's a tradition we began last year, after the pandemic finally let up in June and the lockdown rules were relaxed a bit in July. And that taught us the value of getting going while the going is good, and not waiting for the cold weather and the variants to bring back the bad old days in the fall. So happy Canada Day to our boiling-in-place neighbours to the north, happy Independence Day to all our American friends, and happy fourth, fifth, and the rest of the days of July to all our other readers. See you in August.

PCMI - Your technology partner

 

This Week’s Warranty Week Headlines

Praise for "Nixing the Fix: An FTC Report to Congress on Repair Restrictions."
Auto Body News, July 1, 2021
New right to repair law saves average family money on appliance repairs.
Daily Mirror (UK), July 1, 2021
National Home Service Contract Assoc. elects new officers and director.
Press Release, July 1, 2021
KandyPen Slim vape pens carry lifetime warranties.
Willamette Week, July 1, 2021
J.D. Power and JM&A Group to jointly develop automotive warranty products.
Press Release, July 1, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Mize Inc.

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Fortegra expands partnership with Badcock Home Furniture retail chain.
Press Release, July 1, 2021
Amynta Group acquires Scion Underwriting Services from Brit.
Press Release, July 1, 2021
Asus continues 2-yr. "Perfect Warranty" in UAE, including ADH.
Khaleej Times (AE), July 1, 2021
Have those annoying robocalls for auto warranty services ceased? Here's why.
South Florida Sun-Sentinel, July 1, 2021
Maruti Suzuki extends expiring warranty reprieve to July 31.
Hindustan Times (IN), July 1, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Tavant

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Nissan blames supplier Fiamm Energy for flurry of warranty claims.
Bloomberg News, June 30, 2021
eBay's Certified Refurbished Program includes 2-yr. warranties.
9 to 5 Toys, June 30, 2021
Assurant appoints Lee Coomber to the new role of RAC client director.
AM Online (UK), June 29, 2021
Apple cuts the price of AppleCare+ for select M1 MacBook models.
iLounge (AU), June 29, 2021
Lexus India launches Lexus Life program, including extended warranties.
Press Release, June 29, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines below



After Warranty Analytics

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Americans lost $29.8 billion to phone scams alone over the past year.
CNBC, June 29, 2021
Choice Home Warranty appoints James Mostofi as Chief Executive Officer.
Press Release, June 28, 2021
GuardTree Inc. offers VSCs in Canada to buyers of private-sale used cars.
Globe and Mail (CA), June 25, 2021
Connecticut governor signs updates to the state's equipment dealer laws.
Farm Equipment, June 25, 2021
Alternative Fuel Vehicles are the subject of a warranty roundtable.
Motor Trader (UK), June 25, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Ubiquiti

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Extended warranties for cars are fraught with peril for consumers.
New York Times, June 24, 2021
A basic guide to home warranty coverage.
BBN Times, June 24, 2021
Learn more about vehicle service contracts from Veritas Global.
Press Release, June 24, 2021
Steve Kochurov joins American Auto Guardian as Eastern Regional VP.
Press Release, June 23, 2021
Unwanted robocalls return to ask about your car warranty
KTNV-TV Las Vegas, June 23, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Sign up for a free subscription to Warranty Week:
     subscribe     change of address     unsubscribe


 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Don't waste your money on car warranty calls.
WHTM-TV Harrisburg PA, June 23, 2021
What can you do about car warranty calls?
WCMH-TV Columbus OH, June 23, 2021
Car warranty guide: Everything you need to know.
Kelley Blue Book, June 22, 2021
Calls about extending your car's warranty most common robocall in 2021.
KHOU-TV Houston, June 21, 2021
Crucial says cryptomining voids SSD warranty, then retracts post.
Tom's Hardware, June 19, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines below



sponsored by PCMI

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Weather Warranty sponsors free live webinar on July 13th.
Rental Equipment Register, June 19, 2021
New Automotive Aftermarket Guidelines come into operation on 1 July.
The Citizen (ZA), June 18, 2021
SoClean and Philips argue over CPAP cleaning devices causing defects.
Home Medical Equipment News, June 18, 2021
DRK Resources Tech partners with ServicePower.
Press Release, June 17, 2021
Thor Kitchen to use OnPoint's warranty administration services.
Press Release, June 17, 2021
Good and bad points of extended warranties on cars & bikes explained.
Financial Express (IN), June 17, 2021
Deepview True Cost report says Honda & Toyota have lowest warranty costs.
Wards Auto, June 16, 2021
Carchex denies transmission warranty claim as pre-existing condition.
WFTV-TV Orlando, June 16, 2021
AllPoints doubles the warranty on its Mavrik foodservice brand to 180 days.
Press Release, June 16, 2021
InsurTech firm eMaxx launches alternative energy warranty programs.
Press Release, June 15, 2021
Altra Industrial Motion provides service contracts for aging wind turbines.
Energy Magazine (AU), June 15, 2021
Spoticar CPO program for Vauxhall, Peugeot and Citroen brands launched.
Motor Trader (UK), June 15, 2021
Electric truck maker Lordstown Motors shares slide after CEO and CFO resign.
CNBC, June 14, 2021
OnPoint Warranty Solutions upgrades Louisville, Kentucky, operations.
Area Development, June 14, 2021
Western Digital's 32-terabyte My Cloud appliances have 3-yr. warranties.
IT Pro (UK), June 14, 2021
LG introduces 5-yr. panel warranty for its OLED TVs sold in the U.S.
Forbes, June 11, 2021
Fortis Warranty provides commercial warranty for DC solar project's roofs.
Solar Power World, June 11, 2021
Wrong-sized tires void pickup truck's transmission claim.
WFMY-TV Greensboro NC, June 11, 2021
Why is the car warranty scam so popular?
WUSA-TV Washington DC, June 11, 2021
Onewheel sends entire product registration database to customer by mistake.
Vice News, June 10, 2021
 

More Warranty Headlines